Skip to main content

State vs. Mann - State Side

    

In class, we debated the State vs. Mann case, which regards a slave being beat and shot at by the person who is renting her. My group and I were on the State Side of the debate, arguing that Mann should be held accountable for injuring said slave and should be forced to pay his fine. Our argument was structured upon the basis that due to Mann renting Lydia, and her not being his property, he was simply assaulting her. 

    The State vs. Mann case as a whole dealt with John Mann, from North Carolina, who had rented a slave named Lydia. Lydia was referred to as "disobedient" and in order to handle this, Mann began beating her. In an attempt to avoid the beating, Lydia started running. Mann shot at Lydia while she was running away, and hit her in the back, injuring her. Mann was fined ten dollars, and felt as though he should not be held responsible for paying the fine. The case then worked its way through the system and landed in the Supreme Court.

    For my personal argument, I based it on ethics. The issue at hand was, Mann abused and attempted to murder Lydia, and expected to face zero punishment. By allowing Mann to be refunded his ten dollar fine, it disregards Lydia as any sort of human being. Even if we regard Lydia as property, she was not being beaten by her owner, she was being beaten by a renter. If this was spoken about with true property such as a house, the renter would be liable for destruction they commit on the home they are renting. This point alone should have held Mann responsible for the destruction of Lydia's physical body. 

    Ethically, the ruling was incorrect. Lydia was being harmed by someone who was not even her owner, meaning he had no rights over her. By diminishing Lydia as a person and allowing Mann to not pay his fine, it creates a concept that allows for non-slave owners to potentially have the right to harm slaves that are not theirs. Along with that, the case went against a precedenting case. The preceding case regarded a man who had committed a ruthless crime against his own slave. He was therefore fined and punished by law. Due to the common practice of following precedenting case rulings, the State vs. Mann case should have also held John Mann accountable for the battering and attempted murder of Lydia. 

    

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

About Me

 Hi! My name is Abby Weiss. I'm from Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania, right in the heart of the Poconos. I am an Exercise Science, Pre-PA major, and hope to become a physician's assist in the ER or a Level 1 Trauma Unit. My main goals while attending High Point is to make the most every opportunity, do well in my classes, and make lasting friendships. I have played softball since I was 9, and I will be playing on High Point's club team. I also enjoy snowboarding, skydiving, hiking, traveling, and anything that has to do with water, or being outside. I hope to travel to all 50 states, right now I have been to 18 of them! I am excited for what High Point has to offer, and the opportunities I create for myself due to that. 
Post a Comment
Read more

EOTO Recap - California Reagents v Bakke

 California Reagents v Bakke Mock Trial Recap     In class we had the opportunity to go through the motions of the California Reagents v. Bakke trial. This was a very prominent case, signifying whether affirmative action and minority quotas were Constitutional and would be permitted to continue on within schools and corporations. The case began when Allan Bakke; veteran, NASA intern, and med-school applicant, was denied twice from University of California at Davis. Bakke reportedly had stand out MCAT scores, a high GPA, and decent interviews and was well rounded between the participation in the U.S. Military as well as NASA.      The side of Bakke deemed racial quotas unconstitutional. They said that affirmative action makes it unfair for students who do not fit the certain group standards to be admitted. Based upon solely numerical values such as grades and GPA, Bakke was more than qualified to be admitted to the medical school. Due to...
Post a Comment
Read more

Theme Song

 Theme Song     Music has played a very major role in my life. Many memories, both good and bad, have a musical association for me. I think when you take the time to understand the lyrics of the song, you can find out more about yourself and your views on life. When trying to choose a theme song, I struggled with selecting just one. I believe that I embody many aspects of various songs and genres, and am grateful that I am capable of seeing parts of myself in a multitude of lights. I love to travel, my bags are always packed, and the feeling of freedom is something so pivotal to who I am. I believe there's more to life than the sole aspect of working day in and day out. I also am a strong believer in the idea that you can learn more through travel, than in a classroom. In that aspect, I do not mean traveling to five star resorts and luxurious beaches, I mean travel to touch every part of the world; the good, the bad, and the ugly, meet a variety of people, ...
Post a Comment
Read more